China’s push into Africa: Who really benefits?

JOHANNESBURG – A growing push into the world’s poorest continent has led Beijing to dub 2006 ‘China’s Year of Africa’, but pointed questions are now being asked about who really benefits from the relationship.

After trips to Africa by both President Hu Jintao and Premier Wen Jiabao earlier this year, China will itself play host in Beijing from tomorrow to more than 40 African leaders at a two-day summit. Desperate to find raw materials to power its rapidly growing economy, China has struck deals the length and breadth of Africa in the last year as well as doing business with states regarded as pariahs in the West.”The China-Africa relationship is truly one of equality, friendship and mutual benefit based on the common interests,” China’s ambassador to South Africa, Liu Guijin, said in a speech last week.”There have been quite a few ‘firsts’ this year in China’s relations with Africa, so it can be reliably called ‘China’s Year of Africa’…To consolidate and expand its friendship and cooperation is a long-term strategy pursued by China.”The list of recent agreements include a deal for Beijing to buy phosphates from Morocco in the north while Angola in the south has become one of the main sources of crude imports to the oil-hungry nation.Chinese companies are also involved in a host of construction projects such as the building of a 2,5 billion euro hydro-electric dam in Gabon as part of a project to access iron ore in a remote forest region, while a deal should be concluded this week to fund the rebuilding of the port of Buchanan in Liberia.But while governments appear happy to reel in the investment and take advantage of the attractive loans on offer from China, their opponents are questioning the long-term benefits.The main opposition Patriotic Front leader Michael Sata made attacks on the conduct of Chinese businesses, which now have a foothold in industries ranging from mining to clothing, one of the main themes of his campaign in Zambia’s recent general election.”Instead of employing Zambian labourers they bring hundreds of Chinese,” said Sata in an interview with AFP.”The Chinese should bring their technology, bring their expertise, but use Zambians.”In neighbouring Zimbabwe, President Robert Mugabe is looking forward to the red carpet treatment from his new Chinese allies after being boycotted by the European Union and United States for allegedly rigging his re-election in 2002.The Chinese influence is now such that the government in Beijing is funding a new department at Harare’s state-run University of Zimbabwe that will offer Chinese language and culture courses.Zimbabwe announced in June that it had signed a US$1,3-billion deal with China to set up coal mines and three thermal power stations at Dande, west of Harare, to help end the growing number of power shortages.But behind the headlines, critics say the new relationship has thus far done brought material benefit and failed to reverse Zimbabwe’s economic crisis.”The benefit to Africa is very little.There is a degree of job creation (but) most of the aid has been tied to utilising Chinese inputs, Chinese experts, Chinese technology etc,” said Zimbabwean economist Eric Bloch.”There is no favourable trading balance.Africa has always had to buy from China without selling its own products to China.There is a trend of dumping Chinese seconds and rejects to Africa while the choice grade is sold to buyers in the West.”Ambassador Liu acknowledged there were complaints that China was using Africa as a dumping ground for cheap goods as well as exploiting its natural resources.”They say that China is now milking the African continent of its mineral resources and flooding African markets with its cheap goods.This kind of complaint is not something new to China,” he said.”In the 1990s, Australia, New Zealand and some Southeast Asian countries had exactly the same anxieties.But within a decade, these anxieties abated and vanished.”Nampa-AFPDesperate to find raw materials to power its rapidly growing economy, China has struck deals the length and breadth of Africa in the last year as well as doing business with states regarded as pariahs in the West.”The China-Africa relationship is truly one of equality, friendship and mutual benefit based on the common interests,” China’s ambassador to South Africa, Liu Guijin, said in a speech last week.”There have been quite a few ‘firsts’ this year in China’s relations with Africa, so it can be reliably called ‘China’s Year of Africa’…To consolidate and expand its friendship and cooperation is a long-term strategy pursued by China.”The list of recent agreements include a deal for Beijing to buy phosphates from Morocco in the north while Angola in the south has become one of the main sources of crude imports to the oil-hungry nation.Chinese companies are also involved in a host of construction projects such as the building of a 2,5 billion euro hydro-electric dam in Gabon as part of a project to access iron ore in a remote forest region, while a deal should be concluded this week to fund the rebuilding of the port of Buchanan in Liberia.But while governments appear happy to reel in the investment and take advantage of the attractive loans on offer from China, their opponents are questioning the long-term benefits.The main opposition Patriotic Front leader Michael Sata made attacks on the conduct of Chinese businesses, which now have a foothold in industries ranging from mining to clothing, one of the main themes of his campaign in Zambia’s recent general election.”Instead of employing Zambian labourers they bring hundreds of Chinese,” said Sata in an interview with AFP.”The Chinese should bring their technology, bring their expertise, but use Zambians.”In neighbouring Zimbabwe, President Robert Mugabe is looking forward to the red carpet treatment from his new Chinese allies after being boycotted by the European Union and United States for allegedly rigging his re-election in 2002.The Chinese influence is now such that the government in Beijing is funding a new department at Harare’s state-run University of Zimbabwe that will offer Chinese language and culture courses.Zimbabwe announced in June that it had signed a US$1,3-billion deal with China to set up coal mines and three thermal power stations at Dande, west of Harare, to help end the growing number of power shortages.But behind the headlines, critics say the new relationship has thus far done brought material benefit and failed to reverse Zimbabwe’s economic crisis.”The benefit to Africa is very little.There is a degree of job creation (but) most of the aid has been tied to utilising Chinese inputs, Chinese experts, Chinese technology etc,” said Zimbabwean economist Eric Bloch.”There is no favourable trading balance.Africa has always had to buy from China without selling its own products to China.There is a trend of dumping Chinese seconds and rejects to Africa while the choice grade is sold to buyers in the West.”Ambassador Liu acknowledged there were complaints that China was using Africa as a dumping ground for cheap goods as well as exploiting its natural resources.”They say that China is now milking the African continent of its mineral resources and flooding African markets with its cheap goods.This kind of complaint is not something new to China,” he said.”In the 1990s, Australia, New Zealand and some Southeast Asian countries had exactly the same anxieties.But within a decade, these anxieties abated and vanished.”Nampa-AFP