Ban genital surgery on intersex children – HRW

EW YORK – Genital surgery should be banned on children whose sex characteristics are ambiguous because the procedures can scar young patients for life and be considered human rights violations, a leading rights group said yesterday.

Several hundred so-called intersex children in the United States have undergone sex reassignment surgery in recent years, and worldwide, doctors recommend surgery for an estimated one in every 2 000 intersex babies, US-based Human Rights Watch (HRW) and interACT, an advocacy group, said.

Surgeries to make them resemble more typical boys or girls include the removal of testes or ovaries, deepening shallow vaginas and enlarging small penises, the groups said in a report. They called for a US moratorium on all surgical procedures on intersex children too young to participate in the decision.

The surgeries amount to “human rights abuse taking place in a medical setting,” said Kyle Knight, a HRW researcher.

“These surgeries are medically unnecessary, they are harmful, and they have not delivered on the outcomes that were originally theorised,” he told the Thomson Reuters Foundation in a telephonic interview.

The report said the benefits of sex reassignment surgery remain unproven, but the resulting harm can be catastrophic.

Surgery can cause lifelong pain, sterilisation, loss of sexual sensation and health complications, it said.

About 1,7% of the world’s population, or 127,5 million people are thought to be born intersex, according to the report.

But detailed data on the US intersex population, once called hermaphrodites, is largely lacking, Knight noted. The surgeries’ popularity dates back to 1960s’ research, which concluded intersex people could be assigned typical male or female genitals if operated on early in their infancy, HRW and interACT said.

In a recent open letter cited by the report, three former US surgeons general said plastic surgeries on genital organs “can cause … emotional distress.”

Efforts to warn medical doctors about the risks have been ongoing since the 1990s but met mixed success, the report said.

It found that a growing number of doctors are opposed to recommending surgery on intersex babies unless medically necessary, the report said after interviewing nearly two dozen healthcare practitioners.

Various United Nations’ agencies have condemned the practice as violating fundamental human rights.

– Thomson Reuters Foundation

In an age of information overload, Sunrise is The Namibian’s morning briefing, delivered at 6h00 from Monday to Friday. It offers a curated rundown of the most important stories from the past 24 hours – occasionally with a light, witty touch. It’s an essential way to stay informed. Subscribe and join our newsletter community.