Terror experts say jury out on Qaeda Madrid role

VIENNA – What if it was al Qaeda? Security analysts said on Friday the jury was still out on the possible involvement of Islamist militants in the Madrid train bombings, for which a group aligned to al Qaeda claimed responsibility in an e-mail to an Arab newspaper.

Spain said Basque separatist group ETA was to blame for the bombs that killed nearly 200 people. But after the discovery of a stolen van with detonators and taped verses from the Koran, the government said no lines of inquiry could be ruled out.If al Qaeda or related militant Islamists were involved, the implications would be enormous: the first such strike in the heart of Europe, and the first in the West since the attacks on America on September 11 2001.It would show that the network, after confining itself for the past two-and-a-half years to attacks in mainly Muslim countries like the Gulf, North Africa, Turkey and South East Asia, was capable of hitting “the heart of crusader Europe” and girding for a fresh blow against America, if the e-mail to al-Quds al-Arabi newspaper is to be taken at face value.And it would raise the threat level to European nations such as Britain, Italy and Poland which have closely aligned themselves with the United States in its war on terror and sent their troops to Iraq.Terrorism experts, however, are wary of jumping to conclusions.”The jury is still out,” said Sebestyen Gorka, a security analyst based in Hungary.He said if he was “60-40″ inclined on Thursday to blame ETA, this had now slipped to 50-50.He said the attacks were neither classic ETA nor classic al Qaeda, and the claim of responsibility was a little too neat.”Al Qaeda is well known for either not accepting responsibility or doing so very late,” he said, adding that the email was “a little bit too fast, a little bit too clear”.CLUES POINT BOTH WAYS David Claridge of Janusian Security Risk Management in London said: “There are clues in both directions.The Spaniards seem quite determined to insist it’s ETA… (but) the style, everything about it seems to point to Islamists.”If al Qaeda were involved, he said: “It has massive implications… It’s potentially Europe’s 9/11 in terms of a wake-up call.”Al Qaeda involvement would raise big questions about European intelligence services and governments, who had not alerted their publics by raising threat levels.It could prompt calls to tighten security at internal EU borders, just as 10 mostly East European countries are poised to join the European Union on May 1 and take advantage of freer travel for their citizens.Analysts said there was no shortage of states in Europe that al Qaeda might want to hit.Those that backed the US war on Iraq include not just Britain, Spain, Italy and Poland but a host of countries, both inside and outside the EU, who have sent troops there since.Even prominent war opponents are at risk.France was singled out in a recent audiotape, purported to be from Osama bin Laden’s deputy Ayman al-Zawahri, for its decision to ban Islamic head scarves from state schools.Germany, staunchly opposed to the US-led war against Iraq, has staged prominent al Qaeda trials and played a role in post-Taliban Afghanistan.Spain itself, apart from its Iraq role, has taken an active role in rounding up Islamic militants.Security analyst Gorka said, however, an al Qaeda attack in Europe could rebound against the militants by binding European countries much more tightly into the US war on terror.”This could be an event that brings those countries who were not behind the United States into line, in seeing international terrorism as THE threat to be dealt with,” he said.- Nampa-ReutersBut after the discovery of a stolen van with detonators and taped verses from the Koran, the government said no lines of inquiry could be ruled out.If al Qaeda or related militant Islamists were involved, the implications would be enormous: the first such strike in the heart of Europe, and the first in the West since the attacks on America on September 11 2001.It would show that the network, after confining itself for the past two-and-a-half years to attacks in mainly Muslim countries like the Gulf, North Africa, Turkey and South East Asia, was capable of hitting “the heart of crusader Europe” and girding for a fresh blow against America, if the e-mail to al-Quds al-Arabi newspaper is to be taken at face value.And it would raise the threat level to European nations such as Britain, Italy and Poland which have closely aligned themselves with the United States in its war on terror and sent their troops to Iraq.Terrorism experts, however, are wary of jumping to conclusions.”The jury is still out,” said Sebestyen Gorka, a security analyst based in Hungary.He said if he was “60-40″ inclined on Thursday to blame ETA, this had now slipped to 50-50.He said the attacks were neither classic ETA nor classic al Qaeda, and the claim of responsibility was a little too neat.”Al Qaeda is well known for either not accepting responsibility or doing so very late,” he said, adding that the email was “a little bit too fast, a little bit too clear”.CLUES POINT BOTH WAYS David Claridge of Janusian Security Risk Management in London said: “There are clues in both directions.The Spaniards seem quite determined to insist it’s ETA… (but) the style, everything about it seems to point to Islamists.”If al Qaeda were involved, he said: “It has massive implications… It’s potentially Europe’s 9/11 in terms of a wake-up call.”Al Qaeda involvement would raise big questions about European intelligence services and governments, who had not alerted their publics by raising threat levels.It could prompt calls to tighten security at internal EU borders, just as 10 mostly East European countries are poised to join the European Union on May 1 and take advantage of freer travel for their citizens.Analysts said there was no shortage of states in Europe that al Qaeda might want to hit.Those that backed the US war on Iraq include not just Britain, Spain, Italy and Poland but a host of countries, both inside and outside the EU, who have sent troops there since.Even prominent war opponents are at risk.France was singled out in a recent audiotape, purported to be from Osama bin Laden’s deputy Ayman al-Zawahri, for its decision to ban Islamic head scarves from state schools.Germany, staunchly opposed to the US-led war against Iraq, has staged prominent al Qaeda trials and played a role in post-Taliban Afghanistan.Spain itself, apart from its Iraq role, has taken an active role in rounding up Islamic militants.Security analyst Gorka said, however, an al Qaeda attack in Europe could rebound against the militants by binding European countries much more tightly into the US war on terror.”This could be an event that brings those countries who were not behind the United States into line, in seeing international terrorism as THE threat to be dealt with,” he said.- Nampa-Reuters